Identity Crisis 20th Anniversary Deluxe Edition Review

Someone knows who you are. They know where you live. And they know who you love. This fear haunts every superhero. In 2004, Brad Meltzer turned that fear into a reality. Now, we celebrate a milestone. The Identity Crisis 20th Anniversary Deluxe Edition is finally here. It brings a dark mystery back to life. But does it hold up?

This story changed DC Comics forever. It is not just a fight scene. It is a murder mystery. Elongated Man faces a tragedy. The Justice League breaks apart. Secrets come to light. Therefore, this book is a must-read for historians. However, it remains divisive. Some fans love the drama. Others hate the darkness.

In this review, we dive deep. We analyze the art. We look at the plot. We check the new extras. Is this hardcover worth your money? Let’s find out.

Technical Specifications

Pros and Cons

Pros

• Rags Morales delivers career-defining art.
• The mystery keeps you guessing until the end.
• Deluxe Edition paper quality is superb.
• Includes rare scripts and commentary.
• Explores the human side of heroes.

Cons

• The dark themes are not for everyone.
• Some character choices remain controversial.
• Retcons change classic Justice League history.

Quick Action Checklist

• Read this if: You love murder mysteries. You enjoy grounded superhero stories. You want to see the JLA in a new light.
• Avoid this if: You prefer fun, campy adventures. You dislike grim plot twists. You are sensitive to mature themes.
• Collector’s Note: This edition matches other DC Deluxe hardcovers. It looks great on a shelf.

The Story: A Murder in the Family

It starts with a scream. Sue Dibny is the wife of Ralph Dibny. She is the heart of the team. Suddenly, she is gone. Murdered in her own home. Consequently, the hero community panics. This is not an alien invasion. It is a personal attack.

Brad Meltzer writes a gripping script. He treats heroes like real people. They cry. They fear for their families. Green Arrow narrates the tale. He reveals a dark secret. The League has crossed lines before. Specifically, they messed with a villain’s mind. Dr. Light is the prime suspect.

However, nothing is simple. The plot twists and turns. Everyone is a suspect. Batman investigates with forensic skill. The Flash runs interference. Meanwhile, Tim Drake faces his own crisis. The stakes feel incredibly high. You feel the tension on every page.

Therefore, the story feels heavy. It deals with loss. It deals with memory. It asks hard questions. Should heroes kill? Should they wipe minds? These questions split the team. Thus, the Identity Crisis 20th Anniversary Deluxe Edition captures a pivotal moment.

For more on classic DC stories, check out Hero and Villain World. They have great guides.

The Art: Emotion on Every Page

Rags Morales is the star here. His art is expressive. You see the pain in Ralph’s eyes. You see the anger in Hawkman. Consequently, the book feels like a drama. It is not just action poses. It is acting on paper.

Michael Bair provides the inks. They are clean and sharp. Alex Sinclair adds the colors. The palette is grounded. It fits the somber tone. Furthermore, the covers are iconic. Michael Turner created stunning covers. Sadly, he is no longer with us. This edition honors his work.

In addition, the layouts are dynamic. The panels flow well. The action scenes pop. But the quiet moments shine brightest. A funeral scene is heartbreaking. A conversation in a kitchen feels real. Morales masters body language.

Thus, the art elevates the script. It makes the controversy palatable. Even if you dislike the plot, you will love the art. It is a masterclass in storytelling.

The Deluxe Treatment: What is New?

This is the 20th Anniversary. So, DC gave it an upgrade. The book is oversized. The pages are glossy. The binding is sturdy. It feels premium in your hands.

Moreover, the extras are generous. You get the full script for issue #1. You can see Meltzer’s process. It is fascinating for writers. Also, there is a gallery. It features sketches by Morales. It shows the evolution of covers.

Additionally, there is commentary. The creative team reflects on the work. They discuss the backlash. They discuss the success. It adds context. For a collector, this is gold. It justifies the price tag.

However, do not expect a new story. The main content is the same. It is the presentation that changed. If you own the Absolute Edition, you might skip this. But for new readers, it is perfect. It is the best way to read it today.

The Controversy: 20 Years Later

We must address the elephant in the room. This book is polarizing. In 2004, it shocked everyone. In 2024, it still sparks debate. Some scenes are very dark. The treatment of Sue Dibny upset many fans.

Furthermore, the mind-wipe plot is tricky. It changes how we see the Silver Age. Heroes we loved did bad things. They lied to Batman. They lied to each other. Consequently, it tainted their legacy.

On the other hand, it made them complex. It added layers of grey. It paved the way for Infinite Crisis. It influenced modern comics. Stories became more serious. Stakes became more personal.

Therefore, it is a history lesson. You see where the shift happened. You understand the modern DC Universe better. Love it or hate it, you cannot ignore it. It is essential reading.

If you enjoy deep dives into comic history, visit Hero and Villain World.

Why It Still Matters

Great stories endure. Identity Crisis endures. It touches on universal themes. Trust. Betrayal. Grief. We all relate to these feelings. The costumes are just window dressing. Underneath, it is a human drama.

Moreover, the mystery holds up. The clues are there. The reveal is shocking. Even if you know the ending, the journey is good. You notice new details. You appreciate the foreshadowing.

In addition, the dialogue is sharp. Brad Meltzer is a novelist. He knows how to write dialogue. The characters sound distinct. Green Arrow sounds like a liberal firebrand. Hawkman sounds like a conservative cop. The banter is top-notch.

Consequently, the book reads fast. You fly through the pages. It is a page-turner. The pacing is expert. Each issue ends on a cliffhanger. The collected edition flows seamlessly. It feels like a movie.

Comparing Editions

There are many versions. You have the trade paperback. You have the hardcover. You have the Absolute Edition. Why buy this one?

First, availability. The Absolute is often out of print. The old trades are worn out. This is fresh. It is readily available.

Second, the size. It is larger than a standard comic. But it is smaller than an Absolute. It fits on a normal shelf. It is easier to hold.

Third, the price. It is cheaper than an Absolute. It offers great value. You get the oversized art without breaking the bank.

Therefore, it is the “Goldilocks” edition. It is just right. It balances quality and cost. It is the definitive standard version now.

Final Thoughts on the Plot

Without spoiling too much, the ending is tragic. It is not a happy victory. There are no parades. There is only sadness.

However, this fits the story. It is a noir tale. Noir does not have happy endings. It has consequences. The heroes win, but they lose. They catch the bad guy, but the damage is done.

This realism is its strength. It shows the cost of being a hero. It shows the vulnerability. Superman cannot save everyone. Batman cannot solve every crime instantly. They are fallible.

Thus, it resonates. It feels honest. It strips away the godhood. It leaves us with men and women. They are trying their best. And sometimes, their best is not enough.

Expert Tips for Readers

Read the Tie-Ins?

“You do not need to read the tie-ins. The main book stands alone. However, ‘The Flash’ tie-ins by Geoff Johns are excellent. They add emotional weight to the story.”

Watch for Clues

“Pay attention to the background art. Rags Morales hides clues in plain sight. Look at who is present in scenes. Look at who is missing. The answer is there from the start.”

The Aftermath

“This story leads directly into ‘Countdown to Infinite Crisis’. If you enjoy this, that is your next stop. It sets up the next big event.”

Verdict: Identity Crisis 20th Anniversary Deluxe Edition Review

The Identity Crisis 20th Anniversary Deluxe Edition is a masterpiece of format. The story remains a jagged pill. It is brilliant yet brutal. It is beautiful yet ugly.

Consequently, it earns a high recommendation. The package is perfect. The art is legendary. The story is unforgettable. It demands a spot on your shelf.

Score: 9.0/10

FAQ