DC Heroes

Mister Miracle Review: Pros, Cons And Buyer Feedback

Read our Mister Miracle review: the King–Gerads run in one paperback, what the listing says, and what buyers praise or criticize.

A tangle of chains, a padlock, a cracked hand mirror, and a single key on a dim wooden table, lit from one side.

Mister Miracle collects Tom King and Mitch Gerads’s 2017–2019 DC series in one paperback. This review uses the Amazon listing and buyer reviews, since our team has not read the work and does not own the book.

Disclosure: this article contains an Amazon affiliate link, so the site may earn a commission when you buy through it. The price you pay does not go up. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Transparency note | the Hero and Villain World team does not own this product and has not read it, so this review rests on data checked on Nov 8, 2026.
Quick Take:
  • Who it seems to suit: adult readers who want a character study, because the story is framed as a superhero tale.
  • Strength according to the listing: the full 12-issue run in one paperback, so nothing is split across volumes.
  • Point of caution: one buyer who knew the classic New Gods found the characters off, but others liked it.

What Is Mister Miracle?

Where to buy

Buying through our link does not raise the price you pay. Price and availability can change, so check the store before you buy.

Mister Miracle is a 12-issue DC series from 2017 to 2019, written by Tom King and drawn by Mitch Gerads. According to the listing, this paperback collects all of it. The listing calls Scott Free the world’s greatest escape artist and a celebrity on Earth. However, it also calls him the adopted son of Darkseid.

The listing says Scott and his wife Big Barda live on Earth while Apokolips and New Genesis go to war. Because Darkseid appears to have found the Anti-Life Equation, Scott is the only one left who can stop the slaughter. Therefore, the story mixes a cosmic conflict with a domestic drama.

Note | the listing gives a reading age of 12 years and up. However, buyer reviews mention depression and self-harm, so the book may not suit younger readers or adults sensitive to those themes.
🦸
Find Your Perfect Comic Book in 1 Minute
Answer 4 questions and get 2 personalized recommendations for your reading style
Which universe are you into?
What format do you prefer?
What format do you prefer?
How do you read manga?
What format do you prefer?
What's your reading vibe right now?
What's your budget?

Specs and Edition Details

FIELDDETAILS
TitleMister Miracle, the 2017–2019 series
Source: Amazon listing
WriterTom King
Source: Amazon listing
IllustratorMitch Gerads
Source: Amazon listing
PublisherDC Comics
Source: Amazon listing
EditionPaperback, illustrated edition
Source: Amazon listing
CollectsMister Miracle #1–12
Source: Amazon listing
Page count320 pages
Source: Amazon listing
Dimensions6.61 x 0.51 x 10.2 inches
Source: Amazon listing
Weight1.21 pounds
Source: Amazon listing
Publication dateFebruary 19, 2019
Source: Amazon listing
ISBN-101401283543
Source: Amazon listing
ISBN-13978-1401283544
Source: Amazon listing
LanguageEnglish
Source: Amazon listing
Reading age12 years and up
Source: Amazon listing

Tom King and Mitch Gerads’s 12-issue run gathered in one paperback, with the marriage of Scott Free and Big Barda at its center.

What’s Inside the Mister Miracle Paperback

The listing names Tom King as the writer and Mitch Gerads as the illustrator. It describes a war between Apokolips and New Genesis, but it also describes the marriage of Scott Free and Big Barda. Because Darkseid is Scott’s adoptive father, the family dinner table doubles as a political minefield.

Meanwhile, the listing hints that the Anti-Life Equation may already be working on Scott himself. As a result, the real battlefield seems to be his own perception. The listing asks whether death is the trap waiting for Scott, or whether life itself is.

The listing also quotes editorial reviews. For example, Wired calls the book “heartbreaking, funny, and human,” and The Independent calls it “a meditation on war.” Therefore, readers should expect the cosmic and the domestic to share the page.

Format and What’s in the Package

The Amazon listing gives 320 pages, with dimensions of 6.61 by 0.51 by 10.2 inches and a weight of 1.21 pounds. It also gives English as the language and February 19, 2019 as the publication date. However, the listing does not say whether the volume includes sketches, variant covers, or script pages. Therefore, this review describes the paperback only.

What Buyers Say

Buyer rating on Amazon
★★★★☆ 4.7 out of 5, from 1,499 ratings, on Nov 8, 2026.

Reviews were selected by our team from those Amazon showed on Nov 8, 2026, so they do not represent the average buyer.

What the Higher-Rated Reviews Say

★★★★★

A self-described casual DC fan with gaps in New Gods knowledge went in nervous, but the reader was won over by a relatable, emotional story and the art.

Buyer on Amazon · review selected by our team
★★★★★

One buyer picked up the book because of the buzz and knew the character only from Justice League. However, the buyer found less a cosmic adventure than the account of a man rebuilding his interest in living.

Buyer on Amazon · review selected by our team
★★★★★

A longtime fan who lists the 1980s run, the Kirby issues, and action figures says the reader loves both leads. Because of that history, the book reached someone deep in the lore.

Buyer on Amazon · review selected by our team

What the Lower-Rated Review Says

★★★★★

A reader who came in as a fan of the classic New Gods stories says the characters do not act like themselves and the ending did not work. However, the reader praised the art and the dark humor.

Buyer on Amazon · review selected by our team

Of the 10 reviews sent to our team, 4 gave five stars, 2 four stars, 2 three stars, 1 two stars, and 1 one star. Praise centers on the King–Gerads pairing, the marriage of Scott and Barda, and the handling of anxiety and depression. However, criticism centers on the ending and on the departure from earlier New Gods characterization. In one case, it centers on a damaged copy. Because the selection is small, treat these as first impressions.

Pros and Cons

Pros
  • The paperback collects all 12 issues, so the whole series is in one volume (Amazon listing).
  • A reader without deep New Gods background said the story still worked because it felt relatable (1 of 10 reviews).
  • The listing quotes editorial praise from Wired, GQ, and Publishers Weekly for the King–Gerads pairing (Amazon listing).
  • The listing gives a reading age of 12 and up, so teens fall inside the stated range (Amazon listing).
Cons
  • One three-star buyer, a fan of the classic New Gods, said the characters do not act like themselves (1 of 10 reviews).
  • Another buyer, at two stars, said the pace drops around the halfway point, so the ending does not land (1 of 10 reviews).
  • A one-star buyer received a copy with black marks and torn covers, which is a seller or shipping issue (1 of 10 reviews).
  • The listing does not say whether the volume includes sketches, variant covers, or other extras (Amazon listing).
  • Buyer reviews mention depression and self-harm, so the 12-and-up rating may not suit every reader (buyer reviews).

Who Mister Miracle Is For and Is Not For

Who it is for
  • Readers who want a character-driven superhero story built around a marriage.
  • Fans of Tom King’s other work, since the listing includes his author bio.
  • Newcomers with little New Gods background, because one buyer in that position enjoyed it.
Who it is not for
  • Readers who want the Kirby New Gods stories continued in spirit, since one buyer said the characters feel off.
  • Younger readers or anyone sensitive to depression and self-harm, because buyers mention both.
  • Readers who prefer plot-forward superhero comics, since the listing frames this as a character study.

Is Mister Miracle Worth Reading?

If you want a superhero comic that treats a marriage as the main event, Mister Miracle looks easy to recommend. The listing gives the full run, and its editorial blurbs are strong. Besides, the buyer reviews selected here back up the praise.

However, if you want the Kirby New Gods or a plot-driven war comic, the evidence points the other way. One three-star buyer from that background says the characters act off-model and the ending does not land. Therefore, the answer is conditional: worth reading for fans of character studies, and worth sampling first for fans of the classic material. Price and availability change, so check the store before you buy.

Alternatives by Criterion

If you want the Kirby New Gods in spirit, a collection of the original New Gods issues sits closer to what the three-star buyer expected. Meanwhile, readers who want plot-driven superhero comics can look for a war-focused series instead. Still, neither type was reviewed here.

A 320-page paperback collecting the full King–Gerads series for readers who want the marriage story as much as the cosmic war.

Mister Miracle FAQ

What does Mister Miracle collect?

According to the listing, this paperback collects Mister Miracle #1–12, which is the full King–Gerads series from 2017 to 2019.

Do I need to read the original New Gods comics first?

The editorial reviews quoted in the listing call the book stand-alone, and Kirkus calls it “a solid stand-alone.” However, buyer opinions differ: one reader with little New Gods background enjoyed it, while another who knew the classics found it a departure.

What age is Mister Miracle for?

The listing gives a reading age of 12 years and up. However, buyer reviews mention depression and self-harm, so parents should judge for their own reader before buying.

Who is Mister Miracle best for?

Readers who want a character-driven, marriage-centered superhero story, according to the listing and the buyer reviews. In contrast, readers who want the Kirby New Gods in the same spirit may be disappointed, as the three-star review shows.

How many pages is the Mister Miracle paperback?

The listing gives 320 pages, and the dimensions are 6.61 by 0.51 by 10.2 inches.

Whatever your starting point, Mister Miracle asks a question the listing repeats: what does a man do when the trap has already sprung? The buyer reviews suggest the answer is worth your time, although the three-star report is a fair reminder that it is not for every reader.

Checked data | Checked on Nov 8, 2026. Store: Amazon. Rating: 4.7 out of 5 stars from 1,499 ratings. Time not provided.
Sources
  • Amazon product listing: data and reviews sent by our team on Nov 8, 2026

Notice: our team does not own this product, and the analysis was made from product data and buyer reviews, without our team reading the work. Prices and ratings change, so check before you buy, and affiliate links do not raise the price you pay. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

Share:

Harrison

William Harrison is the founder of Hero and Villain World and has been living among capes and crusaders for as long as he can remember. At 45, he brings four decades of passion to his writing, offering honest reviews, deep-dive character trivia, and the latest buzz on movie adaptations. William’s mission is simple: to connect fans of all ages and celebrate comic book culture in every line he writes.

Author's Website

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *